Verifying reviews means confirming that the reviewer actually performed the review for your journal(s).
 

Verification is a critical part rewarding reviewers and building your journal’s brand. There are 3 tiers of Publons verification.

 

1 Verified reviews from a Publons integration 

When a researcher reviews for a partnered journal and opts in for recognition, we receive the review data directly from the journal’s EMS (e.g. ScholarOne Manuscripts or Editorial Manager) and can therefore be absolutely sure that review happened. 

 

2 Editor Verification

Reviews can be added to Publons manually by researchers using a form. These are not verified by default. To have these reviews verified, the researcher in question can provide the name and contact details for the journal editor or administrator and we send them an invitation to independently verify the review. 

 

3 Email Auditing

Reviews can be added to Publons by researchers by forwarding their ‘Thank you for reviewing’ email to reviews@publons.comThese are not verified by default. We audit the 'Thank you for reviewing' emails against key indicators to determine their legitimacy. If we cannot confirm an email's legitimacy we will contact the reviewer or editor and ask for additional evidence. We also randomly audit "Thank you for reviewing" emails by contacting the editor or journal administrator, and use this to build a network of trust.

 

You can read more here